Desi Return
ServicesToolsResource HubBlogAboutContact Us
Plan Your Return
Blog / Financial Planning / Podcast
Podcast

Why We Left Canada for India: Financial Planning & Housing Lessons

Watch this episode on its own page

Santosh predicted Canada's housing and healthcare crisis 5 years ago. Now living in India, he shares financial planning for 3 scenarios (equity, underwater, break-even), real monthly expenses (₹1 lakh for family), and why CAD vs INR depreciation argument is flawed.

Avinash, article author
Avinash
21 Aug 202512 min read55 min watchUpdated 30 Nov 2025
In this story
  1. 01What Santosh Predicted 5 Years Ago
  2. 023 Financial Scenarios for Canadians
  3. 03CAD vs INR Myth Debunked
  4. 04Monthly Expenses in India
  5. 05Key Advice
Free tool · no signup

RNOR & move-date optimiser

Check the 729-day rule against your actual dates and see how long your RNOR window runs.

Check your window
In this story
  1. 01What Santosh Predicted 5 Years Ago
  2. 023 Financial Scenarios for Canadians
  3. 03CAD vs INR Myth Debunked
  4. 04Monthly Expenses in India
  5. 05Key Advice
Financial Planning • Last Updated: November 30, 2025
Left Canada Before It Got Worse: Santosh's Financial Planning & Housing Insights

Santosh predicted Canada's crisis 5 years ago. Now in India, he shares financial planning for different scenarios and debunks the CAD vs INR myth.

By Avinash, NRI Return Specialist with 8+ years helping families relocate successfully 📅 Published: August 21, 2025 | 🔄 Last Updated: November 30, 2025
Canada Return Financial Planning Housing Crisis Follow-up Interview

What Santosh Predicted 5 Years Ago

  • Housing crash: "45% GDP on housing is complete BS"
  • Healthcare crisis: "Last hospital built in 1950, population 20K→180K"
  • Immigration unsustainable: Mass immigration without infrastructure
  • Trudeau government fall: "This will bring down the government badly"
"People were laughing at me 5 years ago. Now everyone knows—someone from their society or relative is already in stress."

Ask us one thing

What's the one thing holding your return back?

Everyone's move gets stuck on something different — a 401k nobody will explain, RNOR timing, which city, whether the schools work out. Tell us yours in a sentence and we'll come back with a specific answer, not a brochure.

Question 1 of 3

No spam. Just a direct, useful answer.

3 Financial Scenarios for Canadians

Scenario 1: Have Equity

Bought for $1M, now worth $1.4-1.5M, put 20% down, paid some mortgage:

  • Have ~$600-700K equity
  • Transfer via Remitly—good rates
  • Split: 1-2 Cr in FD, rest in stock market/SIP

Scenario 2: Underwater

Bought for $1M, now worth $800K:

  • Transaction costs: ~$100K (land transfer tax $32-35K, mortgage break fee $15-50K, real estate fees $50K)
  • Options: Wait it out, come up with $100K to close, or hand over keys and leave
  • "Sit and pray—if you're broken and can't take more, hand over keys and run"

Scenario 3: Break-Even

Can exit cleanly—decide based on job stability, health, India plans.

CAD vs INR Myth Debunked

"CAD was ₹63 in 2009, still around same. You get 3% in Canadian GIC vs 8% in Indian FD. Even if CAD becomes ₹73 (15% appreciation), the 8% yield in India still beats Canada. Do the math."

Monthly Expenses in India

₹1 Lakh Budget (No Mortgage)

  • Car EMI: ₹20K (10 lakh car)
  • Groceries: ₹20K (everything included)
  • Rent: ₹30K (decent 2-3BHK)
  • Remaining: Utilities, health, travel

"Ashirwad atta is same for Ambani as for you—₹400. Grocery cost doesn't change much with income."

Key Advice

  • Run your own numbers—don't get influenced by videos
  • Use ChatGPT to calculate scenarios
  • Have a stable job plan for India
  • Don't compare—India and Canada are different

Planning Your Canada to India Move?

Join the Inner Circle

Share this article
WhatsAppLinkedInXFacebookEmail

Ask us one thing

What's the one thing holding your return back?

It could be taxes, timing, school, retirement, or where to settle. Tell us the one thing.

Question 1 of 3

No spam. Just a direct, useful answer.

The episode
Format
Video conversation
Length
55 min
Recorded
21 Aug 2025
Watch the conversation
Free tool · no signup

RNOR & move-date optimiser

Check the 729-day rule against your actual dates and see how long your RNOR window runs.

Check your window
FAQ

Questions people ask

Santosh outlines 3 scenarios: '1) Have equity (bought early, house worth more)—transfer via Remitly, split between FD and investments. 2) Underwater (bought at peak, house worth less)—either wait it out, come up with $100K to close, or hand over keys and leave. 3) Break-even—can exit cleanly.' Transaction costs: ~$100K for million-dollar house (land transfer tax, mortgage break fee, real estate fees).
Santosh's breakdown: '₹1 lakh minimum for two people (no rent/mortgage): Car EMI ₹20K, groceries ₹20K, rent ₹30K (decent 2-3BHK), remaining for utilities, health, travel.' He adds: 'With ₹2-4 lakh income, can live lavish life including Fortuner.' This is for comfortable middle-class lifestyle in tier-1 cities.
Santosh debunks the CAD appreciation myth: 'CAD was ₹63 in 2009, still around same. You get 3% in Canadian GIC vs 8% in Indian FD. Even if CAD becomes ₹73 (15% appreciation), the 8% yield in India still beats Canada returns. Do the math—use ChatGPT if needed.' He recommends: 'Split: 1-2 Cr in FD, rest in stock market/SIP.'
Santosh's advice for underwater mortgages: 'Either wait it out (if you can afford payments), come up with $100K to close the gap, or hand over keys and leave.' He warns: 'People who bought at peak are stuck. Transaction costs ~$100K for million-dollar house.' Some are choosing to walk away rather than stay trapped in negative equity.
Santosh predicted this 5 years ago: '45% GDP on housing is complete BS. Last hospital built in 1950, population 20K→180K. Mass immigration without infrastructure.' He says: 'People were laughing at me 5 years ago. Now everyone knows—someone from their society or relative is already in stress. This will bring down the government badly.'
Santosh recommends: 'Transfer via Remitly—good rates.' For large amounts from house sale: 'Split between FD (1-2 Cr for safety) and stock market/SIP for growth.' He emphasizes doing the math on CAD vs INR returns rather than assuming CAD will appreciate significantly.
Keep reading

Related guidance

Desi Return YouTube thumbnail explaining why an Indian SIP can be a US PFIC for a returning taxpayer
Podcast · Financial Planning

Don't Start an Indian SIP Before You Understand PFIC

NRI and returning to India India tax filing guide — avoid income-tax notices, file ITR correctly for FY 2025-26
Podcast · Financial Planning

NRI and Returning to India: File Your Taxes Correctly Before a Notice Arrives

RNOR Status Tax Benefits: Eligibility, Duration, Foreign Income Rules guide image for Desi Return readers
Guide · Financial Planning

What Is RNOR Status in India? Benefits, Duration and Rules

After the story

Their sequence, applied to your move.

Turn what worked for one family into a dated plan across tax, money, documents, and logistics.

Start your planner
Desi Return

We help NRIs and the Indian diaspora who are considering moving back or retiring in India make their transition smooth and successful with expert guidance, community support, and tailored resources.

Useful Links
AboutServicesContact UsFind Us Online
Explore
Resource HubToolsPlannerBlogPodcastFAQ
© 2026 Desi Return. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms and Conditions
Partner services are fulfilled directly by the independent companies named above; Desi Return may earn a referral fee at no extra cost to you. Nothing on this page is tax, legal, or financial advice — always confirm specifics with the partner or your own advisor.
Your bag

Your bag is empty. Add a service to get started.